Randal Rauser
    • About Randal
    • Books
    • Articles
      • Articles (single)
      • Articles (in series)
    • Audio/Video
      • Audio Interviews, Lectures, and Debates
      • Video Interviews and Lectures
      • Powerpoint Slides
    • Blog
      • Current Posts
      • Blog Archives
    • Podcasts
      • The Tentative Apologist
      • 59 Second Apologist
    • Reviews
    Search the site...
    • Home
    • The Tentative Apologist
    • Do you need to know how the internal witness of the Holy Spirit works in order to receive an internal witness of the Holy Spirit?

    Do you need to know how the internal witness of the Holy Spirit works in order to receive an internal witness of the Holy Spirit?

    August 14, 2018 / Randal / The Tentative Apologist / No Comments

    Many Christians claim to form justified beliefs based on a spiritual experience (e.g. the internal witness of the Holy Spirit) or a spiritual cognitive faculty (e.g. the sensus divinitatis). The skeptic retorts: ” Wait, how is this internal witness (or this sensus divinitatis) supposed to work?”

    Now, this is a perfectly fair question. However, it is also perfectly fair for the Christian to reply, “I have no idea.”

    The skeptic replies indignantly: “But how can you form justified beliefs from a spiritual experience or cognitive faculty if you don’t know how it works?” And I’ll reply in kind:

    “I assume you have justified beliefs about your current bodily location. And you also have justified sense perceptual beliefs about your immediate environment. And you have justified beliefs based on your memory, and your rational intuition, and testimony. Do you know how proprioception, sense perception, memory, rational intuition, and the epistemology of testimony all function? Is that knowledge of cognitive function requisite for gaining justified beliefs from these various doxastic faculties? Surely not.”

    “Hold on,” the skeptic says. “There’s a big difference between those universal, common, mundane faculties and your so-called internal witness of the Holy Spirit.”

    “Is there?” I reply. “Let’s take the first example: proprioception. Many people suffer various degrees of proprioceptive malfunction. How widespread would that malfunction need to be before the person with a properly functioning proprioceptive capacity would be required to explain how it functions in order to be justified in accepting the deliverances of proprioception? And why is that threshold required? Who decides such things?”

    Share
    epistemology, religious belief, religious epistemology, sensus divinitatis

    Follow This Blog

    Randal’s Books at Amazon.com

    What’s So Confusing About Grace?


    Randal-Rauser_An Atheist and a Christian Walk into a BarAn Atheist and a Christian Walk into a Bar…

    Randal-Rauser_Is-the-Atheist-my-NeighborIs the Atheist My Neighbor?: Rethinking Christian Attitudes toward Atheism

    Randal-Rauser_What-on-earth-do-we-know-about-heavenWhat on Earth Do We Know About Heaven?: 20 Questions and Answers about Life after Death

    Randal-Rauser_The Swedish Atheist, the Scuba Diver and Other Apologetic Rabbit TrailsThe Swedish Atheist, the Scuba Diver and Other Apologetic Rabbit Trails

    Randal-Rauser_God or Godless?: One Atheist. One Christian. Twenty Controversial QuestionsGod or Godless?: One Atheist. One Christian. Twenty Controversial Questions.

    Randal-Rauser_You're Not As Crazy As I Think: Dialogue in a World of Loud Voices and Hardened OpinionsYou’re Not As Crazy As I Think: Dialogue in a World of Loud Voices and Hardened Opinions

    Randal-Rauser_Finding God in The ShackFinding God in The Shack

    Randal-Rauser_Faith Lacking Understanding: Theology 'Through a Glass, Darkly'Faith Lacking Understanding: Theology ‘Through a Glass, Darkly’

    Randal-Rauser_Christian Philosophy A-ZChristian Philosophy A-Z

    Randal-Rauser_Theology in Search of FoundationsTheology in Search of Foundations

    Recent Posts

    • Is Theistic Evolution a Contradiction in Terms? A response to J. Warner Wallace
    • Rethinking Origins: The Evolution of a Young Earth Creationist
    • Give a Little Bit: My Super-Duper Christian/Skeptic Anti-Malaria Fundraiser!
    • Everything Wrong with This Christian Worldview Chart
    • Should we be certain of our beliefs? Or should we doubt?

    Archives

    Browse Blog Archives by Title >>

    © Randal Rauser - a steady site