Randal Rauser
    • About Randal
    • Books
    • Articles
      • Articles (single)
      • Articles (in series)
    • Audio/Video
      • Audio Interviews, Lectures, and Debates
      • Video Interviews and Lectures
      • Powerpoint Slides
    • Blog
      • Current Posts
      • Blog Archives
    • Podcasts
      • The Tentative Apologist
      • 59 Second Apologist
    • Reviews
    Search the site...
    • Home
    • The Tentative Apologist
    • How does the failure to define naturalism affect Lowder’s argument for naturalism from the history of science?

    How does the failure to define naturalism affect Lowder’s argument for naturalism from the history of science?

    July 18, 2012 / Randal / The Tentative Apologist / 5 Comments

    In retrospect, it may have been good to put this at the end of my previous article. But better late than never. How does Lowder’s failure to define naturalism adequately affect his argument for naturalism from the history of science? To put it mildly, it doesn’t do it any favors.

    First, let’s recount the argument itself (which I’ve excerpted from here):

    If there is a single theme unifying the history of science, it is that naturalistic explanations work. The history of science contains numerous examples of naturalistic explanations replacing supernatural ones and no examples of supernatural explanations replacing naturalistic ones. Indeed, naturalistic explanations have been so successful that even most scientific theists concede that supernatural explanations are, in general, implausible, even on the assumption that theism is true. Such explanatory success is antecedently more likely on naturalism–which entails that all supernaturalistic explanations are false–than it is on theism. Thus the history of science is some evidence for naturalism and against theism. (emphasis added)

    So what is this thing called naturalism that is more compatible with the history of science than is theism?

    As I’ve argued, Lowder cannot give a clear example. Thus, things end up looking like this:

    Tom and Marsha awoke to a thump in the darkness. Marsha opined, “I think Billy is trying to sneak in his window after staying out too late.”

    But Tom had a different hypothesis. “I say that x made the sound.”

    Marsha looked at Tom quizzically. “What exactly is x supposed to be Tom?”

    “X is the hypothesis that something natural made the sound. Maybe it was the sump pump. Or the wind blowing a branch against the window. Who knows what we’ll find out?”

    Marsha looked skeptical. “And what if it was Tom?”

    “Well then Tom made the sound by some part of his body contacting some part of the window sill, in which case it really was a natural cause anyway.”

    Marsha (rolling her eyes): “I’m going back to sleep.”

    Share
    atheism, Jeffrey Jay Lowder, materialism, naturalism, science, theism

    Follow This Blog

    Randal’s Books at Amazon.com

    What’s So Confusing About Grace?


    Randal-Rauser_An Atheist and a Christian Walk into a BarAn Atheist and a Christian Walk into a Bar…

    Randal-Rauser_Is-the-Atheist-my-NeighborIs the Atheist My Neighbor?: Rethinking Christian Attitudes toward Atheism

    Randal-Rauser_What-on-earth-do-we-know-about-heavenWhat on Earth Do We Know About Heaven?: 20 Questions and Answers about Life after Death

    Randal-Rauser_The Swedish Atheist, the Scuba Diver and Other Apologetic Rabbit TrailsThe Swedish Atheist, the Scuba Diver and Other Apologetic Rabbit Trails

    Randal-Rauser_God or Godless?: One Atheist. One Christian. Twenty Controversial QuestionsGod or Godless?: One Atheist. One Christian. Twenty Controversial Questions.

    Randal-Rauser_You're Not As Crazy As I Think: Dialogue in a World of Loud Voices and Hardened OpinionsYou’re Not As Crazy As I Think: Dialogue in a World of Loud Voices and Hardened Opinions

    Randal-Rauser_Finding God in The ShackFinding God in The Shack

    Randal-Rauser_Faith Lacking Understanding: Theology 'Through a Glass, Darkly'Faith Lacking Understanding: Theology ‘Through a Glass, Darkly’

    Randal-Rauser_Christian Philosophy A-ZChristian Philosophy A-Z

    Randal-Rauser_Theology in Search of FoundationsTheology in Search of Foundations

    Recent Posts

    • Rethinking Origins: The Evolution of a Young Earth Creationist
    • Give a Little Bit: My Super-Duper Christian/Skeptic Anti-Malaria Fundraiser!
    • Everything Wrong with This Christian Worldview Chart
    • Should we be certain of our beliefs? Or should we doubt?
    • Would you indoctrinate your child to save their soul?

    Archives

    Browse Blog Archives by Title >>

    © Randal Rauser - a steady site