John Howard Yoder (d. 1997) remains one of the most influential Protestant theologians and ethicists of the latter twentieth century. He was also a serial sexual predator. Over several decades, he groomed women for his own sexual gratification, thereby perpetuating spiritual abuse, sexual abuse, and clergy sexual abuse. Estimates are that he abused at least one hundred women. The sickening irony is that he exploited his status as a Christian pacifist preaching an uncompromising gospel of non-violence all while wreaking emotional and psychological anguish upon his many survivor-victims.
I have known of Yoder’s morally corrupt legacy for years. And all that while I have thought it morally grotesque that Christian ethicists continue to use Yoder’s works, particularly his much lauded book The Politics of Jesus, both for intellectual study and to form the next generation of seminarians. But I never wrote on the issue. Instead, it remained a grumble, a gripe.
That has now changed. I recently took an afternoon to read Rachel Waltner Goossen’s excellent 2015 article “‘Defanging the Beast’ Mennonite Responses to John Howard Yoder’s Sexual Abuse.” Goosen’s article lays out in detailed fashion the way that Christian leaders and organizations downplayed Yoder’s abuse and made excuses for him, often based on a woefully misbegotten application of Matthew 18. Goossen’s article has reignited my interest in seeing Yoder’s work consigned to the paper shredder and recycle bin.
To clarify, I am not advocating for “book burning” or any other form of censorship. Nor am I arguing that Yoder shouldn’t be studied at all. The writings of many awful people are proper objects of study. But they are proper objects of study as second-order works of history, not as first-order contributions to the field. I heartily agree that Yoder’s works should be studied for their historical impact. To ignore them would be to create a gaping hole in the development of late twentieth century Protestant ethics. But it is quite a different matter to engage in the first-order study of these writings as ethical and theological works on their own terms. By all means, study The Politics of Jesus to trace its historical impact. But for goodness’ sake, don’t study it as a guide to become more like Jesus. That is what I believe should end.
Allow me to anticipate the response of the Yoder apologist. “You are atop a slippery slope. If we toss Yoder’s work, where do we stop? After all, every theologian, ethicist, or scholar is a fallible, sinful being to some degree! What is more, your argument is a non sequitur. It falsely assumes that we cannot separate Yoder’s scholarly output from his personal decisions. But we can!”
I disagree on both accounts. Yes, we are all sinners. But we are not all serial sexual predators. And I actually do believe that Yoder’s work and life are inseparable and defending the use of the former inevitably makes you an apologist of sorts for the latter.
The Peter Singer Analogy
Consider an analogy. Peter Singer is widely considered to be the world’s leading philosophical defender of animal rights, and his 1975 book Animal Liberation is lauded as a classic of the movement. In short, Animal Liberation is to animal rights as The Politics of Jesus is to Christian pacifism.
Imagine if throughout his career, Singer had trained pitbulls to fight in a dog-fighting network. And Singer then developed a pseudo-academic rationalization to justify his continued participation in dog-fighting in a baldly self-serving attempt to make it consistent with his public views on animal liberation. In that extraordinary situation, do you think Animal Liberation would still be praised as a veritable Bible of the movement and used even down to today to train the next generation of animal rights activists?
I don’t think so. For all his brilliance, if Singer had been such a glaring hypocrite, if he brazenly abused dogs while preaching animal rights, I am convinced he would’ve been marginalized from the animal rights movement and his work would’ve been consigned to the dustbin. Sadly, I believe that animal rights activists have a clearer moral vision than many Christian ethicists.
Here’s one important detail. As with our analogy, Yoder didn’t simply abuse women. He developed a pseudo-academic rationalization to justify his continued participation in sexually abusing women in a baldly self-serving attempt to make it consistent with his public views on Christian ethics. Beginning in the early 1970s, Yoder began developing what he promoted as a new Christian ethic of sexuality which involved an exploration of what he called “familial” relationships between men and women which would involve “non-sexual” touching, disrobing, and even vaginal penetration. Yoder solicited women through his church and academic contexts to be his test subjects and to work with him in the exploration of his “theories”. They “tested” his “theories” in classrooms, homes, parking lots, and God knows where else.
Not surprisingly, Yoder never invited other men to test his “theories” with women. It was always Yoder who opted to include himself as a test subject in his own study. To my knowledge, he never published any formal results from his “rigorous tests” with dozens of women which could explain his “theories” or subject them to critical academic scrutiny. But whenever he was challenged on his actions, he was ready to use his sharp acumen, apparent capacity for endless verbiage and bafflegab, and imposing personality to silence dissent.
In the rest of this article, I want to argue my case that treating Yoder’s academic writing as a proper object of study and ethical formation has a corrupting impact on those who advocate for it. My claim is that Yoder was such a brazen huckster and predator that his entire academic career is inextricably interwoven with his prolific life as a sexual predator. And as a result, I believe that Christians who treat the two as separable functionally become Yoder advocates by downplaying and misrepresenting his predatory abuse. I will make my case by considering the way that Yoder’s most famous devotee, Stanley Hauerwas, has continued to defend the master.
The Stanley Hauerwas Test Case
Hauerwas met Yoder in the early 1970s. From that time, Yoder had a monumental impact on Hauerwas. Indeed, Hauerwas identified Yoder as the one who convinced him to become a pacifist. Hauerwas, in turn, was key in bringing Yoder to teach at Notre Dame in the 1970s. The lives and legacies of these two ethicists are inextricably bound together.
I don’t know the extent of Hauerwas’ knowledge of Yoder’s sexual exploits, but it is fair to assume that it was likely formidable. After all, going back to the mid-1970s, Yoder was issuing public appeals for test subjects. Hauerwas worked closely with Yoder for more than two decades. And in the 1990s he was involved in calls for Yoder to be accountable to his history of abusing women.
Despite this, when Hauerwas published an elegy remembering his friend in First Things in 1998, it was all glowing praise, ending with the statement, “we can rejoice in that grain of the universe God made present in the life of John Howard Yoder.” Absent is any acknowledgement of Yoder’s history of sexually exploiting and abusing women. This is the very definition of whitewashed history.
Hauerwas does deign to acknowledge Yoder’s many victims in his 2010 memoir Hannah’s Child. He writes,
“How John’s community responded to his inappropriate relationships with women, for all the ambiguities and confusions associated with that response, is also a lesson in its own right. It is a testimony to a community that has learned over time that the work of peace is slow, painful, and hard.” (Hannah’s Child: A Theologian’s Memoir (Eerdmans 2010), 246).
Note that Hauerwas never mentions sexual harassment, clergy sexual abuse, or spiritual abuse. Instead, he describes Yoder’s history of sexual predation with the forgiving euphemism “inappropriate relationships.” As grotesque as that is, arguably the worst part of Hauerwas’ statement is the suggestion that the very people Yoder exploited and abused may have found solace and healing through Yoder’s pacifistic theology, albeit in a journey that was “slow, painful, and hard.”
Our final example of Hauerwas playing the apologist for Yoder comes from a 2017 interview in which Hauerwas was asked about the continued use of Yoder’s work given his abuse of women. In the interview clip (included below), Hauerwas acknowledges that this is an important issue and that some have decided to marginalize Yoder’s theology in response. But Hauerwas nonetheless says he would still teach Yoder’s work including The Politics of Jesus, albeit with an “asterisk.” For Hauerwas, Yoder’s career of sexual predation is an “asterisk” on his career.
But the next thing Hauerwas says is arguably far worse. Hauerwas offers the following explanation for Yoder’s actions:
“John, being brilliant as he was, stupidly had a theory. He had a theory that said, the mainstream tells us that men and women can only touch one another if they’re married, but for brothers and sisters in Christ, surely it must be the case that there can be nonsexual forms of touching that are not, that it’s not adultery. Well, that was just crazy. But he thought that that was part of the eschatological possibilities that is suggested in the New Testament. I think he was just wrong.”
Here’s the problem: twenty years after Yoder’s death, Hauerwas still accepts at face value and thus promotes Yoder’s rationalization that he had developed a genuine novel eschatological and ethical “theory” borne of his reading of the New Testament. And thus, Hauerwas implies that Yoder’s sexual and spiritual abuse of dozens of women was simply the outworking of his admittedly errant “theory”.
I have restrained myself from making any Nazi analogies in this article, but I can restrain myself no longer. Imagine if someone said that the Nazi physician Josef Mengele “stupidly had a theory” about twins which was “crazy” and “just wrong.” We would immediately recognize that despite the strong disagreement with Mengele, this framing would already have conceded far too much by tacitly conceding that there was some element of legitimate (though misguided) theorization undergirding his “tests” on twins. On the contrary, we unequivocally denounce Mengele’s pathetic attempt to rationalize crimes against humanity with a theoretical overlay.
Obviously, I’m not saying that Yoder is morally equivalent to Mengele. But I am saying that from a conceptual standpoint his attempt to dress up his systemic sexual and spiritual abuse of women with the guise of an ethical and theological extraplolation of eschatological New Testament exegesis is equally absurd. Thus, granting Yoder’s framing of his morally abhorrent actions with a (misguided) theological and ethical framework, as Hauerwas does here, simply extends the work of the Yoder apologist.
To sum up, Hauerwas begins in 1998 by not even acknowledging Yoder’s predatory history, instead lauding the man as something approximating a saint. Twelve years later he will acknowledge “inappropriate relationships” though he perversely suggests that healing from the “inappropriateness” may have been spurred by Yoder’s own theological legacy of pacifism. And even in 2017, Hauerwas is still presenting Yoder’s serial sexual predation as a misguided “theory” borne of his reading of the New Testament.
In my view, that pattern of covering up and misrepreseting Yoder’s predatory history is a natural outworking of Hauerwas’ commitment to Yoder’s theological and ethical legacy as a continued dialogue partner and source of theological and ethical formation. The two cannot be separated. If you continue to defend Yoder’s theological and ethical work as an important source of study for theological and ethical formation, I believe you will thereby be predisosed to misrepresent the heinousness of his actions in a manner that extends the legacy of his abuse.
John Howard Yoder was a serial sexual predator. So please, stop studying him as a wise Christian ethicist.

