• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Randal Rauser

Home of progressively evangelical, generously orthodox, rigorously analytic, revolutionary Christian thinking (that's what I'm aiming for anyway)

  • About
  • Books
  • Articles
    • Articles (single)
    • Articles (in series)
  • Audio/Video
    • Audio Interviews, Lectures, and Debates
    • Video Interviews and Lectures
    • Powerpoint Slides
  • Blog
    • Current Posts
    • Blog Archives
  • Podcasts
    • The Tentative Apologist Podcast
    • Archived Podcasts
    • Reviews

Essential beliefs

April 9, 2013 by Randal

Walter commented:

“I recently skimmed a blog post by C. Michael Patton over at Parchment and Pen where he created a diagram showing what he considered to be the essential and non-essential doctrines that comprise orthodox Christian belief.

“The fighting began almost immediately in the comments section.”

This is not a problem unique to Christian or religious identity. Consider:

What beliefs do you have to hold to be a:

Republican

deep ecologist

Chicago school economist

libertarian

naturalist

scientist

atheist

Ask questions about these identities and immediately you’ll find yourself mired in disputes.

Now let’s make it even more disputatious. Ask yourself:

What beliefs must you deny to be a:

Republican

deep ecologist

Chicago school economist

libertarian

naturalist

scientist

atheist

Once again, the answers will quickly mire us in raucous debate.

Now ask:

What beliefs do you have to hold (and deny) to be an exemplary:

Republican

deep ecologist

Chicago school economist

libertarian

naturalist

scientist

atheist

Nobody escapes these kinds of debates without significant bruising.

What irks me is how people sometimes focus these kinds of essentialist questions on communities widely recognized to be religious as if the lack of consensus on precisely the set of beliefs one must hold (and deny) to be a minimal (or exemplary) member of the community is somehow a special problem for religion. But it isn’t. Essentialist questions relating to complex social identities are always contentious and will always be fuzzy on some of their edges.

Filed Under: The Tentative Apologist Tagged With: essentialism, heresy, orthodoxy

Footer

Against Malaria Foundation

Against Malaria Foundation

Support Kiva

Support Kiva

Search this website

Archives



Copyright © 2023 • Randal Rauser • A Steady Site